Why Most People Don’t Stick to Their New Year’s Resolutions
- Wole Akosile
- 4 days ago
- 4 min read
(And the Fix Nobody Talks About)
Every January, the same movie plays.
You wake up on January 1st feeling lighter — like this year has fresh air in it. You’re motivated. Clear. Determined.
You write the list:
Get fit
Save money
Drink less
Wake up early
Be consistent
Finally, “get it together”
And for a little while... it works.
Then February hits.
Life gets loud again. Work ramps up. Sleep gets messy. Someone gets sick. Your calendar fills. Your energy dips. You miss a day. Then two.
And suddenly you’re staring at that familiar thought like it’s a receipt you didn’t ask for:
“Why can’t I ever stick to my New Year’s resolutions?”
If that’s you, here’s the truth that changes everything:
You’re not lazy. You’re not weak. You’re not “undisciplined.”
You’re human — trying to follow a plan designed for a robot.
Let’s talk about why resolutions fail so often… and what actually makes change stick.
Table of Contents
Why New Year’s Resolutions Fail So Often
Most resolutions aren’t built on how change works in real life.
They’re built on how change works in fantasy life — the version where you have:
consistent motivation
stable energy
minimal stress
plenty of time and mental space
predictable weeks
Real life rarely offers any of that.
So what happens?
You start strong. Then you hit normal life pressure. You fall behind. And then you do the most human thing possible:
You blame yourself.
Motivation doesn’t disappear because you stop caring. It fades first when life gets harder.
The Discipline Myth (and Why It Quietly Wrecks Your Progress)
When resolutions fail, the usual advice is:
“Just be more disciplined.”
Discipline can help — but it’s strongest under ideal conditions: when stress is low, your routine is stable, and your nervous system feels safe.
Here’s the part people don’t say out loud:
Most New Year’s resolutions are designed for ideal conditions, not real life.
When you’re tired, overwhelmed, emotionally stretched, or under pressure, your brain shifts into protection mode. Your nervous system prioritises survival, not self-improvement.
So you can want the change deeply, and still struggle to sustain it.
That’s not a character flaw. That’s biology.
How to Stick to New Year’s Resolutions (What Actually Helps)
Lasting change isn’t about trying harder.
It’s about designing goals that work with human psychology — not against it.
Here are five strategies that turn “January motivation” into something that survives February.
1. Choose Fewer Goals Than You Think You “Should”
The fastest way to fail is to try to change everything at once.
When you stack too many goals, you overload your brain. Your attention scatters, your energy drains, and even small setbacks feel like proof you “can’t do it.”
Instead:
Pick one priority. Maybe two.
That’s not laziness. That’s strategy.
Because consistency matters more than ambition.
Try this: If you had to choose the one change that would make the biggest difference by June, what is it?
2. Make Your Goal Behaviour-Based, Not Identity-Based
Many resolutions are actually self-criticism in disguise.
“I need to be more disciplined.”
“I’m bad at routines.”
“I need to fix myself.”
Those aren’t goals. They’re shame.
And shame is heavy. Heavy doesn’t move well.
Swap identity goals for behaviour goals:
“Walk for 10 minutes after dinner.”
“Prep lunch the night before, twice a week.”
“Put my phone outside the bedroom by 10:30 pm.”
You’re not trying to become a new person. You’re practising a new action.
3. Start Smaller Than Feels Impressive
Most people start too big. Then burn out. Then quit.
If your plan requires constant high motivation, it’s not a plan — it’s a mood.
A weird rule that works:
If your goal feels slightly underwhelming, you’re probably doing it right.
Small actions do three powerful things:
build confidence
reduce avoidance
create momentum
Intensity is fragile. Repetition is not.
Example upgrades:
Not “gym 5 days a week” → “gym 2 days + one 10-minute walk”
Not “cut out sugar” → “dessert only on weekends”
Not “meditate 30 minutes” → “3 minutes after brushing teeth”
4. Plan for Low-Energy Days (This Is the Game-Changer)
Most people plan their resolutions for their best days.
But your best days don’t need a plan. Your hardest days do.
When you only allow the “full version” of a habit, you create an all-or-nothing trap:
Do it perfectly… or not at all
Miss once… and spiral
Fall behind… and quit
Instead, ask:
What does this goal look like on a hard day?
What’s my minimum version that still counts?
Minimum versions keep habits alive when motivation drops.
Examples:
Exercise → “2 minutes of stretching counts.”
Writing → “Write one sentence.”
Healthy eating → “Add one piece of fruit today.”
You’re not lowering the standard. You’re building resilience into the system.
5. Measure Consistency, Not Perfection
Missing a day doesn’t ruin progress. Quitting does.
Progress is built by returning — not by never slipping.
So instead of asking:
“Did I do this perfectly?”
Ask:
“Did I return to it?”
A powerful mindset shift:
Don’t aim for never missing.
Aim for never abandoning.
A Different Way to Think About Change
If you’ve struggled with New Year’s resolutions before, it doesn’t mean change isn’t for you.
It usually means the strategy didn’t match the reality of your life.
Change works best when it’s:
realistic
compassionate
flexible
designed for humans, not ideals
You don’t need more pressure.
You need a structure that supports you when motivation fades — because motivation always fades.
That’s not pessimism. That’s planning.
One Final Thought
You didn’t fail your New Year’s resolutions because there’s something wrong with you.
Most people struggle because they’re trying to change under conditions that make change genuinely hard.
Understanding that isn’t an excuse.
It’s the starting point for doing things differently — this time, in a way that actually lasts.
A Question to Sit With
If this felt familiar, you’re not alone. If you feel comfortable sharing, what’s one resolution you’ve struggled to sustain — and what might a smaller, more realistic version look like?
This article is for general information and reflection only and is not a substitute for personalised mental health care.
Comments